Protecting Bookkeepers Since 2005
We're a team of insurance specialists who understand the unique challenges bookkeepers face. Our mission is to provide comprehensive, affordable protection so you can serve your clients with confidence.
Our Story
Contractor's Choice Agency was founded in 2005 with a simple mission: provide specialized insurance solutions for professional service firms that general insurers often overlook.
We quickly discovered that bookkeepers and accounting professionals faced unique liability risks that required specialized coverage. Generic business insurance left too many gaps—and when claims arose, bookkeepers found themselves exposed.
Today, we're one of the leading providers of professional liability insurance for bookkeepers across all 50 states. We've helped thousands of accounting professionals protect their practices, their reputations, and their livelihoods.
Our team includes former accountants who understand your daily challenges, insurance veterans who know the coverage landscape, and client service specialists dedicated to making the insurance process as simple as possible.
Our Values
These principles guide everything we do.
Protection First
We believe every bookkeeper deserves comprehensive protection. Our goal is to ensure you can focus on your clients without worrying about liability.
Client-Centered
Your success is our success. We take time to understand your unique practice and recommend coverage that truly fits your needs.
Industry Expertise
We specialize in professional liability for bookkeepers and accountants. This focus means better coverage and better service.
Always Available
Insurance questions don't always arise during business hours. Our team is here when you need us, with prompt responses to all inquiries.
Why Bookkeepers Choose Us
- Industry Specialization
We focus exclusively on professional liability for accounting professionals, which means better coverage and better rates.
- Multiple Carrier Access
We work with multiple A-rated carriers to find you the best coverage at the most competitive price.
- Claims Support
When you have a claim, you need an advocate. We're with you every step of the way.
- Fast, Easy Process
Get a quote in minutes, not days. Our streamlined process respects your time.
- Licensed Nationwide
We're licensed in all 50 states, so we can help no matter where you practice.
Meet Our Founder
Josh Cotner
Founder & Principal Agent
With over 20 years of experience in insurance and a deep understanding of professional service firms,Josh Cotner founded Contractor's Choice Agency to provide specialized protection for bookkeepers and accountants who were underserved by traditional insurers.
Ready to Protect Your Practice?
Join thousands of bookkeepers who trust us to protect their livelihoods. Get a customized quote in minutes.